[ Rules / FAQ ] [ meta / b / media / img / feels / hb / x ]

/feels/ - Advice & Venting

Talk about relationships of all kinds, ask for advice, or just vent
Name
Email
Message

*Text* => Text

**Text** => Text

***Text*** => Text

[spoiler]Text[/spoiler] => Text

Image
Direct Link
Options NSFW image
Sage (thread won't be bumped)


Check the Catalog before making a new thread.
Do not respond to maleposters. See Rule 7.
Please read the rules! Last update: 04/27/2021

idon'tloveyou.jpeg

MCR and monoculture Anonymous 112335

i was listening to my chemical romance a little earlier today and i felt a bit nostalgic for early 2000s emo culture. i remember how widespread emo and rock was (in the US at least) back then, and how simply being born in the early 2000s meant that you had some panoply of emo bands and songs that connected you to others of a similar time period. nowadays, emo is dead and you don't really see bands as universally venerated and, in my opinion, culturally impactful as MCR. everyone's music tastes and interests are different these days as the world becomes more globalized and "connected," in a paradoxical way.

weirdly, you can compare this a bit to religion. in a religiously homogenous nation like the US used to be, people are more likely to be more familiar with the bible, the story and values of christ, and the moral foundations for which christianity provides. in an irreligious nation, how would you know that your neighbor shares the same values of peace as you do? i can imagine that perhaps might lead to a lack of trust among people, and perhaps this is what people miss and value about religion.


do you guys kind of sense a lack of monoculture in modern culture? everyone's interests and attention are diverted everywhere, our values have become more and more isolated and individualistic. which is maybe not a bad thing by itself, but sometimes i feel like i have nothing in common with others and it contributes to this feeling of societal atomization. i maybe think this is why art consumption and discussion is so important in a country. if you feel similar, what kind of things or media do you think could revive a sense of a monoculture?

also this post may be rambly or incorrect in some way sorry

Anonymous 112348

I miss when white people used to make good music. wtf happened?

Anonymous 112354

Not really, yes we have diverse interests and live in an era where everything is consumable content and AI slop will only make it worse, but you can't tell me there aren't homogenous patterns still around. You have capeshit, you have trap music/mumble rap, you have old internet nostalgics, you have nintendofags and so on.

I honestly think we just forgot how to talk to each other and bond beyond our forced scenarios like school or work. And it's all of us, not just the ugly ones or the losers or whatever. We're lonelier than ever and it shows when it feels like you cannot discuss some media, the easiest thing to talk about out there.

Anonymous 112375

The Film Theorists made a video about this exact topic about 4 months ago

Anonymous 112376

>>112375
really? what video

Anonymous 112386

>>112376
How YouTube Broke Your Brain. MatPat talks about personalized social media algorithms being responsible for the disappearance of the monoculture, and how tragedies have become the only thing EVERYBODY can discuss

Anonymous 112459

>>112386
i think i actually watched that video. is that the one where he talks about how marvel is becoming bad? might have to rewatch later, i enjoy film and game theory quite a bit and its sad matpat left.

i was thinking about it a bit more and, it's not like a monoculture, by virtue of simply being culturally homogenous, is good. i mean, there are countries where the rule of religion has inhibited progress, individual freedom, and the standard of living in some way. i guess what i'm moreso trying to point out is that it feels like the US used to have more of a creative monoculture. you watch older comedy shows and the abundant use of referential humor (honestly i dont really like referential humor but, still) shows that people used to have more aligning interests.

when i think of MCR, i think of an instance in which creative people are given a community and an opportunity to create a sort of cultural landmark for monoculture. like imagine if they got picked up by some soulless TV show's music company or through tiktok instead of being the result of a lively subculture and supportive producers that cared about honing their talent. even the way creatives are portrayed in media, the whole "failing artist who can't support themselves", shows that there's not as much community or support for creative people as there used to be, and why opportunities to create a monoculture fail. kind of like game of thrones, which could have been a major cultural landmark if not for HBO and DND dropping the ball.

this was a huge tangent, kinda poorly written, and went off a random point in retrospect but eh. hopefully you get what i mean

Anonymous 112460

>>112459
also
i dont necessarily think or am suggesting a monoculture by itself is good. i just think it can compliment the presence of external sub and counter cultures
idk how to encapsulate the sentiment fully but i think the distinction is important. or something



[Return] [Catalog]
[ Rules / FAQ ] [ meta / b / media / img / feels / hb / x ]