>>24537
it gets overshadowed by silent hill 2 but I personally think 3 is the best due to Heather's personality and how her fears are expressed in the town

>>24538
Same here 3 has excellent music too

omg I'm so happy someone made a thread on this!!! sh3 was the first sh game I ever played and it's always been my fav even after finishing the entire series.

I do agree it gets overshadowed by sh2 bc of and I find that kinda sad.

Also I can't fucking stand moids sexualising Heather. she's 17.

>>24554
overshadowed by sh2 bc of "muh deep storyline".

Idk why some of my shit got deleted but there u go.

>>24554
>>24555
I think it gets overshadowed by sh2 because a lot of gamers were male during its release and couldn't relate nearly as much as I do.

>>24555
>>24582
I have never felt or seen 3 being overshadowed by 2, 4 is the overshadowed game.

I can't see this game without thinking of a cringe situation I was in involving it. eurgh I hate myself.

>>24620
Even though people joke about how hot heather is I've seen a lot of people say sh3 is shallow and basic in comparison to 2. this is what i mean when I say overshadowed its not shallow or basic not even in comparison to 2.

>>24636
moids are just upset it has a female protag

>>24636
It had less endings than the previous games removing a lot of replayability and was a sequel to the first game which had a plot that barely told you anything.
>>24681
Prove it? I doubt a lot of girls played 3 at least when it came out and I've seen nothing but praise for Heather as the best female protagonist in any game.

Absolutely adore this game
The music in SH3 is unironically better than the music in SH2

Which Silent Hill game(s) has the girl because I only want to play those.

>>24732
I believe it's technically only 3, maybe Shattered Memories but I've never played it and frankly don't care too.

SH2 has a Born from a Wish segment which is about the main female protagonist of 2 who you play as. It's more of a side story you can play after you beat 2.

Speaking of, 1-3 are probably the only games worth their salt. PT could've been great potentially but we will never know, so it's a dud. Really though, whatever they set to do with the series is completed within the first 3 games. Everything has a subtle hand within each game to make a perfect trilogy. People see 2 as somehow a separate entity on it's own but everything that happens in 1 can explain the events of 2. They're all good games, easily emulated and I'd recommend to play them in succession to one another but 3 can be played stand alone if you only want to play a girl protag.